Does Carbon Steel Rust? How to Fix and Prevent It

The Smarter Scrubber's stainless steel chainmail resting in The Original carbon steel skillet, the kind of scrubber that takes rust off

To fix rust on a carbon steel pan, scrub the rust off down to bare metal, dry the pan on the burner, wipe on a very thin coat of high-smoke-point oil and heat it until it stops smoking. Surface rust doesn't ruin the pan, and you can usually have it back on the stove the same day.

You left the pan in the sink overnight, or put it away a little damp, and now there are orange spots on it. It happens to everybody who cooks on carbon steel, and here's exactly how we fix it in the shop.

Does Carbon Steel Rust?

Yes, carbon steel can rust. It's mostly iron, so rust shows up when water sits on it or the seasoning wears thin. A seasoned pan that gets dried and oiled after you wash it rarely rusts, and when it does, the rust stays on the surface and scrubs off.

Why Carbon Steel Rusts

Carbon steel is bare iron and carbon. There's no coating on it, which is the whole point, but it also means water can get to the steel anywhere the seasoning is thin.

The usual causes:

  • Soaking it or leaving it in the sink
  • Putting it away before it was completely dry
  • Running it through the dishwasher
  • Scrubbing hard enough to take the seasoning off in spots
  • Acidic food like tomatoes, wine, or vinegar wearing the seasoning thin, especially on a newer pan

How to Fix Rust on a Carbon Steel Pan

1. Scrub it down to bare metal

Use whatever you have. Steel wool, a chainmail or stainless scrubber, or a scouring pad all work. Soap and water are fine here. Keep going until the rust is gone and you can see gray steel where it was.

Don't worry about the seasoning around the rust spot. If some of it comes off, you'll put it back in a minute.

2. Dry it on the burner

Towel it off, then set it on the stove over medium heat for a minute or two. You want every bit of water gone, including what's hiding around the rivets.

3. Wipe on a thin coat of oil while it's warm

Use a high-smoke-point oil: canola, vegetable, grapeseed, or Crisco. Skip olive oil and butter for this part.

Put a little on a paper towel, rub it over the whole cooking surface, then take a clean paper towel and wipe most of it back off. It should look almost dry. Too much oil is what makes seasoning sticky.

Our Carbon Steel Seasoning tin works here too. You use it exactly the same way as any other oil.

4. Heat it until it stops smoking

Put the pan back on the burner. The oil will smoke for a bit. When the smoke dies down, that layer has bonded to the steel. Turn off the heat and let it cool.

5. Go cook something

Cooking is the best seasoning there is. For the first few meals after a rust fix, cook something with some fat in it: bacon, potatoes in oil, onions in butter or grease. Hold off on eggs, fish, and tomato sauce until the spot has built back up.

If the Rust Covered Most of the Pan

If you scrubbed a big area down to bare steel, give it a full oven seasoning after step 2:

  1. Wipe on a very thin coat of high-smoke-point oil, inside and out, then wipe off the excess.
  2. Set the pan upside down in the oven at 450–500°F for an hour.
  3. Turn the oven off and let the pan cool inside it.
  4. Repeat two or three times.

More detail on that in our guide to how to season a carbon steel pan.

It'll Look Patchy for a While

The spot you scrubbed will be lighter than the rest of the pan. That's normal. As you cook, it darkens and blends in.

A carbon steel pan isn't supposed to be one even shade of black. Brown, bronze, and black patches are just seasoning building up in layers.

How to Keep Rust From Coming Back

This is the routine we use on our own pans:

  • Wash it. A little dish soap is fine.
  • Towel it dry right away.
  • Set it on the burner for a minute to drive off the last of the water.
  • Wipe on a thin coat of oil while it's still warm.

And don't soak it, don't leave it in the sink, and don't put it in the dishwasher.

Rust Isn't a Defect

Every registered Texas Pan is covered by our limited lifetime guarantee. It covers defects in materials and craftsmanship. It doesn't cover surface rust, and that's because rust isn't damage. It's something you fix at the stove.

If you've scrubbed it and it keeps coming back, or you're not sure what you're looking at, email us a photo at sales@texaspancompany.com. One of us will take a look.

Carbon Steel Rust FAQs

Does carbon steel rust easily?

More easily than stainless steel, and about as easily as cast iron, since both are bare iron under the seasoning. If you dry it on the burner and wipe on a thin coat of oil after washing, it rarely rusts.

Is my pan ruined?

No. Surface rust scrubs off, and the steel underneath is fine.

Can I cook on it after the rust is gone?

Yes. Once it's scrubbed, dried, and re-seasoned, cook on it like normal.

Do I need to strip the whole pan?

Usually not. Just scrub the rusty spots and season those areas. Only do a full oven seasoning if most of the pan went down to bare steel.

Why did my pan rust when I dried it?

A towel doesn't get all the water, especially around the rivets and the rim. That's why we put the pan on the burner for a minute after drying it.