If you want a skillet with no nonstick chemicals and no PFAS, the simplest answer is a pan with no coating at all: carbon steel, cast iron or stainless steel. Bare metal can't shed a coating it doesn't have.
Here's what the labels mean, how the uncoated pans compare, and why we make ours the way we do.
What PFAS Means in Cookware
PFAS is a large family of man-made chemicals, sometimes called "forever chemicals." In cookware, the one most people know is PTFE, the slick coating sold as Teflon. PTFE is itself a PFAS. PFOA is a different PFAS that was once used to make PTFE coatings.
That's why a label that says "PFOA-free" doesn't mean "PFAS-free." A pan can be PFOA-free and still have a PTFE coating. If you want to avoid PFAS, look for a pan with no synthetic nonstick coating at all.
Skillets With No Coating
Carbon steel
Carbon steel is mostly iron with a small amount of carbon, rolled into sheet and formed into a pan. It's lighter than cast iron, heats up quickly, and takes very high heat. With seasoning, it gets slick enough for eggs.
Cast iron
Cast iron is poured into a mold, so it's thicker and heavier. It holds heat well and seasons the same way carbon steel does. If weight doesn't bother you, it's a good uncoated pan. We compare the two in Carbon Steel vs. Cast Iron.
Stainless steel
Stainless has no coating and needs no seasoning. Food sticks more easily, so it takes preheating and fat to cook eggs or fish without sticking.
What about ceramic?
Ceramic nonstick is usually sold as PTFE-free. It's still a coating, though, and coatings wear over time. If your goal is a pan with nothing on the surface to wear off, bare metal is the surest choice.
Where the Nonstick Comes From: Seasoning
Carbon steel and cast iron get their nonstick surface from seasoning: thin layers of cooking oil baked onto the steel until they bond into a hard, slick layer. It's oil and heat, not a manufactured coating.
Seasoning builds as you cook. Fatty foods like bacon help early on. If it wears thin in a spot, you can add it back with a little oil and heat. Our guide to seasoning a carbon steel pan walks through it.
How to Care for an Uncoated Pan
- Wash it by hand. Hot water and a scrubber. A little dish soap is fine.
- Dry it right away. Put it on the burner for a minute. Carbon steel and cast iron rust if they stay wet.
- Oil it lightly. Wipe on a thin coat of oil while it's warm.
- Keep it out of the dishwasher. No overnight soaks either.
If rust shows up, it's fixable. Here's how to care for your pan.
How We Make Ours
The Original is our 11-inch carbon steel skillet, made by hand in our shop in Gilmer, Texas, from domestic 12-gauge carbon steel. There's no coating on it: no PTFE, PFOA or other PFAS. We pre-season every pan by baking grapeseed oil onto it for one hour at 500°F, so it's ready to cook when it arrives.
- 11" overall, 8.5" cooking surface
- 3 lb 14 oz
- Handle attached with three American-made copper rivets
- $225, with free US shipping
- 45-day trial and a limited lifetime guarantee on registered pans
It's one pan meant to last, made of steel and seasoning and nothing else.
FAQs
Is carbon steel PFAS-free?
Bare carbon steel has no coating, so there's no PTFE or other PFAS on the pan. Some carbon steel pans are sold with a coating, so check the listing. Ours has none.
Is "PFOA-free" the same as "PFAS-free"?
No. PFOA is one PFAS. A PFOA-free pan can still have a PTFE coating, and PTFE is a PFAS.
Is seasoning a coating?
Seasoning is cooking oil baked onto the steel until it bonds. It isn't a synthetic chemical coating, and you can rebuild it at home with oil and heat.
Can I cook eggs in a carbon steel pan?
Yes, once it's preheated and has some fat in it. A new pan gets easier with a few fatty meals first.