Carbon Steel vs. Cast Iron: Which Skillet Should You Buy?

Texas Pan Company carbon steel skillet over an open fire

Carbon steel and cast iron cook a lot alike: both handle high heat, work on induction, go in the oven and over a fire, and build a naturally nonstick surface through seasoning. The difference is that carbon steel is thinner, lighter and smoother, so it heats up and cools down faster and is easier to move around, while cast iron is heavier and holds heat longer. If you want one pan you'll reach for every day, carbon steel is usually the easier one to live with.

Carbon Steel vs. Cast Iron at a Glance

Carbon steel Cast iron
How it's made Cut and pressed from sheet steel Poured into a sand mold
Weight Lighter for the same size Heavier, often 5 to 8 lb for a 10 to 12 inch skillet
Heat response Heats and cools quickly, easy to adjust Slow to heat, slow to cool
Heat retention Good Excellent
Cooking surface Smooth Often slightly pebbled
Nonstick Seasoning, no coating Seasoning, no coating
Heat sources Gas, electric, induction, oven, grill, open fire Gas, electric, induction, oven, grill, open fire
Care Wash, dry, thin coat of oil Wash, dry, thin coat of oil

How They're Made

Cast iron is poured as molten iron into a mold, which is why it comes out thick and heavy. Carbon steel starts as flat sheet steel that gets cut and pressed into shape. That's how we make The Original in our shop in Gilmer, Texas: we cut each pan and handle from domestic 12-gauge carbon steel, press them on a hydraulic press, season them, and set the handle with copper rivets by hand.

Pressing sheet steel gives you a thinner wall and a smoother surface than a casting, and that's where most of the cooking differences come from.

Weight

This is the one most people notice first. A carbon steel pan is lighter than a cast iron pan of the same size. The Original is 11 inches across and weighs 3 lb 14 oz, which makes it easy to lift with one hand, toss vegetables in, or pack for a camping trip.

Cast iron's weight isn't all bad. It's part of why cast iron holds heat so well. But if a heavy skillet ends up living in the cabinet instead of on the stove, a lighter one gets used more.

Heating and Control

Carbon steel heats up faster and responds faster when you change the heat. Turn the burner down and the pan follows within a minute or so, which helps with eggs, fish, pan sauces and anything that can go from done to burnt quickly.

Cast iron takes longer to come up to temperature and longer to cool off. Once it's hot it stays hot, which is great for searing a stack of steaks back to back or baking cornbread, and less great when you need to back the heat off in a hurry.

Searing

Both sear well. Cast iron's heat retention means it drops less temperature when cold meat hits the pan. Carbon steel gets hot fast and handles very high heat, so a thick 12-gauge pan like ours sears hard too, especially once it's fully preheated.

Seasoning and Nonstick

Neither pan has a chemical coating. There's no PTFE (Teflon), PFOA or other PFAS in either one. Both get their nonstick surface from seasoning: thin layers of oil baked onto the metal until they bond into a hard, slick layer that builds every time you cook with fat.

Carbon steel's smoother surface tends to get slick a little sooner. Our skillets come pre-seasoned with grapeseed oil, baked on for an hour at 500°F in our shop, so you can cook on one the day it arrives. For the first couple of weeks, cook fattier foods and save eggs for once the seasoning has built up. Our guide to seasoning a carbon steel pan covers the details.

Care

Care is nearly the same for both. Wash with a little soap if you want, towel dry, set it on the burner for a minute, and wipe on a thin coat of oil while it's warm. Don't soak either one or put it in the dishwasher. Both can rust if left wet, and both come back with a quick scrub and re-season (here's how to fix rust on carbon steel).

One difference: a sudden temperature change, like cold water on a hot pan, can warp carbon steel and can crack cast iron. Let either one cool before it hits water.

Which One Should You Buy?

Pick carbon steel if you want a lighter everyday pan, quick heat control, a smoother surface for eggs and fish, or one pan you can take from the stove to the grill to a campfire.

Pick cast iron if you mostly do long, steady cooking like cornbread, braises or searing batch after batch, you don't mind the weight, or you want the lowest price.

Plenty of cooks own both. If you're choosing one to use every day, we think carbon steel is the better place to start, and that's why we build The Original: an 11-inch carbon steel skillet made by hand in Gilmer, Texas, from domestic 12-gauge steel, pre-seasoned and covered by a limited lifetime guarantee.

If you've decided on carbon steel and want to compare brands, our buyer's guide to the best carbon steel skillets made in the USA puts five American-made pans side by side on price, weight, guarantee and discounts.

Carbon Steel vs. Cast Iron FAQs

Is carbon steel better than cast iron?

Neither is better at everything. Carbon steel is lighter and more responsive. Cast iron holds heat longer. For an everyday pan, many cooks prefer carbon steel.

Is carbon steel lighter than cast iron?

Yes, for the same size. Our 11-inch skillet weighs 3 lb 14 oz.

Does carbon steel work on induction?

Yes. Carbon steel and cast iron are both magnetic, so both work on induction.

Do carbon steel and cast iron have nonstick chemicals?

No. Neither has a synthetic coating. The nonstick surface on both is seasoning, which is baked-on oil.

Can I use metal utensils on carbon steel?

Yes. Metal spatulas and chainmail scrubbers are fine on carbon steel and cast iron.